Mountain Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Arielle Roman | Union | Catcher | Senior |
| Tamia Howell | Union | Outfielder | Senior |
| Kaiya Simpkins | Union | Outfielder | Freshman |
| Alyssa Thomas | Union | Pitcher | Junior |
| Isabella Fuentes | U.C. | 1st Base | Junior |
| Gabby Velona | U.C. | 3rd Base | Junior |
| Dustina Benvenuto | U.C. | Pitcher | Junior |
| Jess Natunen | Summit | 3rd | Senior |
| Kasey Walsh | Summit | SS | Sophomore |
| Hannah Lyman | S.P.F | 3rd | Senior |
| Amanda Venezia | S.P.F | 2nd / Pitcher | Senior |
| Brianna Manresa | Brearly | Centerfield | Junior |
| Nikki Smith | Brearly | SS | Senior |
| Maggie Phillips | Dayton | 1st | Senior |
| Kayla Mahy | Dayton | SS | Sophomore |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Eliabeth Arios | Union | SS | Junior |
| Lauren Baran | Union | Outfield | Senior |
| Gianna Peralta | U.C. | SS / P | Sophomore |
| Sarah Ohnmeiss | UC | Catcher | Junior |
| Brianna Bowles | Brearly | 3rd / Pitcher | Freshman |
| Bella Casolaro | Brearly | Second Base | Freshman |
| Caitlin Ryan | Brearly | Pitcher / 1st | Senior |
| Cassidy Novello | S. Plains | Catcher | Junior |
| Maeve Kahora | S. Plains | Pitcher | Freshman |
| Jesse Thompson | Dayton | Pitcher | Sophomore |
| Nicole Cataldo | Dayton | Pitcher | Sophomore |
| Victoria Delia | Dayton | Centerfield | Junior |
| Gianna Acitelli | Summit | Outfield | Junior |
| Maddie Murphy | Summit | 1st | Sophomore |
Watchung Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Emma Cieslinski | Roselle Park | PP / 1B | 11 |
| Madison Hummei | Roselle Park | P | 12 |
| Victoria Zatko | ALJ | SS | 12 |
| Megan Tinger | ALJ | C | 11 |
| Morrigan Gardiner | Cranford | P | 10 |
| Morgan Heim | Cranford | 1B | 10 |
| Elizabeth McCaffery | Cranford | SS | 10 |
| Emma Pietrewicz | Westfield | RF | 10 |
| Julia Romano | Westfield | SS | 12 |
| Erica Lawrence | Westfield | C | 12 |
| Evan Pallitta | GL | OF | 11 |
| Julian Lopes | GL | P | 12 |
| Emma Ruiz | Elizabeth | 2B | 10 |
| Mayanah McIntosh | Elizabeth | P | 11 |
| Michaela Hobson | Westfield | P | 10 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Madison Cielinski | Roselle Park | 2B | 11 |
| Alexis Cieslinski | Roselle Park | RF | 11 |
| Sarah Lippin | Roselle Park | CF | 11 |
| Meghan Mooney | Roselle Park | SS | 12 |
| Gabrielle Scott | Roselle Park | DP | 11 |
| Bailey Rosenmeier | ALJ | 1B | 12 |
| Lia D’Angelo | ALJ | 2B | 11 |
| Hannah Brogan | ALJ | RF | 12 |
| Nicole Pecoraro | ALJ | P | 12 |
| Nicole Randazza | ALJ | 3B | 11 |
| Erin Schwerdtfeger | Cranford | C | 12 |
| Jayna Mallon | Cranford | 2B | 12 |
| Jessica Schmidt | GL | 3B | 12 |
| Sofia Mouchtaris | GL | 1B | 12 |
| Jane Morabito | GL | 2B | 12 |
| Julia McConekey | GL | P/OF | 11 |
| Kayla Cardozo | Elizabeth | 3B | 9 |
| Sabrina Ferreira | Elizabeth | SS | 9 |
| Aliria Macaluso | Westfield | 3B | 9 |
| Kalea Calugay | Westfield | CF/P | 9 |
| Molly Stogner | Westfield | 2B | 10 |
| Julia Gagliardi | Westfield | DP/C | 11 |
Valley Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Jocelyn Vega | Benedictine | P | 12 |
| Aimee Vega | Benedictine | 3B | 11 |
| Olivia Tirso | Benedictine | SS | 12 |
| Yasclin Gonzalez | Benedictine | C | 12 |
| Molly Burke | Benedictine | 1B | 12 |
| Victoria Hawk | Oak Knoll | 3B | 9 |
| Shannon Costello | Oak Knoll | C | 12 |
| Lauren Meehan | Oak Knoll | P | 12 |
| Morgan Connelly | New Providence | 3B | 10 |
| Megan Mohan | New Providence | P | 11 |
| Ava Garay | Rahway | OF | 12 |
| Tatiana Dilollo | Rahway | SS | 9 |
| Kelsey Burrows | Kent Place | C | 11 |
| Gabby Alpert | Kent Place | SS | 12 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Gabriela Cortez | Benedictine | CF | 10 |
| Cara Minter | Oak Knoll | SS | 10 |
| Sarah Kowalewski | New Providence | SS | 12 |
| Kayla Biakney | Rahway | 1B | 10 |
| Sarah Johnson | Kent Place | CF | 12 |
| Caitey D’Alessandro | Oak Knoll | CF | 11 |
| Laniya Vargas | Rahway | OF | 11 |
Sky Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Ayanna Heyward | Linden High | 3B | 11 |
| Dianelys Garcia | Linden High | P/C | 11 |
| Keyla Francia | Plainfield HS | CF | 12 |
| Estner Veras | Plainfield HS | RF | 11 |
| Kayla Brice | Plainfield HS | SS | 12 |
| Deniesha Green | Plainfield HS | 2nd | 12 |
| Kayla Haywood | Roselle Catholic | SS | 11 |
| Colleen Badalis | Roselle Catholic | 3B | 12 |
| Grace Enderle | Roselle Catholic | P | 10 |
| Aaliyah Cartagena | Roselle | Cathcher / SS | 11 |
| Amari Perez | Roselle | 2nd Base+Pitcher | 12 |
| Synai Murray | Roselle | 2nd, 3rd, + SS | 9 |
| Azajanana Whitfield | Plainfield HS | 1st | 11 |
| Kaitlyn Matta | Roselle Catholic | C | 12 |
| Madison Dixon | Roselle | Pitcher | 10 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Elieen Currera | Linden HS | 1B | 10 |
| Jasmine Pedro | Linden HS | SS | 11 |
| Gloriani Mercado | Plainfield HS | C | 11 |
| Jocelyn Santiago | Roselle Catholic | CF | 11 |
| Kayla Vaval | Roselle | CF | 11 |
| Autumn Green | Linden HS | P/C | 12 |
| Jaliah Meralla | Roselle | OF | 11 |
| Jalisa McKay | Roselle Catholic | OF | 10 |
| Yusmely Bernal Vargas | Plainfield HS | LF | 11 |
| Anaya Milian -Cruz | Roselle | OF | 10 |