Watchung Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Aiden Plick | Cranford | 1B | 11 |
| Jimmy Shriner | Cranford | OF | 12 |
| Kevin Donovan | Cranford | P | 12 |
| Josh Ciano | Elizabeth | SS | 11 |
| Drew Compton | Governor Livingston | 3B | 12 |
| John Grill | Governor Livingston | OF//P | 12 |
| Andy Serretti | Governor Livingston | IF | 12 |
| Daniel Wilkinson | Scotch Plains Fanwood | P | 12 |
| William Gale | Scotch Plains Fanwood | OF | 12 |
| Patrick Cuccurullo | Scotch Plains Fanwood | P | 12 |
| Zach Fernandez | Union | P | 12 |
| Mike Velez | Union | 1B | 12 |
| Matt McIntyre | Westfield | OF | 12 |
| Michael Catanzaro | Westfield | P | 12 |
| Andrew Caminiti | Westfield | SS | 12 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Jake DeClerico | Cranford | SS | 11 |
| Jeremy Ruka | Cranford | P | 12 |
| Marcus Johnson | Cranford | OF | 10 |
| Andre Tirso | Elizabeth | OF/P | 12 |
| Brandon Vasquez | Elizabeth | OF/P | 11 |
| Joe DeFeo | Governor Livingston | P | 12 |
| Chris Bruno | Governor Livingston | C | 12 |
| Jarod Abram | Governor Livingston | P | 11 |
| Michael Delsordo | Governor Livingston | SS | 11 |
| Dean Kirian | Scotch Plains Fanwood | OF/2B | 11 |
| Nicolas Merkel | Scotch Plains Fanwood | P | 12 |
| Jonathan Ramos | Scotch Plains Fanwood | SS | 12 |
| Rody Martinez | Union | C | 11 |
| Nick Saraceno | Union | 2B | 11 |
| Sean Flynn | Westfield | OF | 12 |
| Chris Ho | Westfield | OF/P | 10 |
Mountain Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Kyle Adorno | Arthur L. Johnson | OF | 10 |
| Stephen Harrington | Arthur L. Johnson | SS | 11 |
| Saul Lopez | Arthur L. Johnson | 3B | 11 |
| Patrick Brennan | Arthur L. Johnson | C | 11 |
| Patrick Grady | Arthur L. Johnson | P | 11 |
| Max Carmino | Arthur L. Johnson | P | 11 |
| Chris Kubas | New Providence | C | 12 |
| Dylan Bedder | New Providence | P/1B | 12 |
| Matthew Reddy | Summit | P | 12 |
| Will Hellings | Summit | P/SS | 12 |
| Daniel Isralowitz | Summit | OF | 12 |
| Trevor Mutolo | Summit | OF | 12 |
| Justin Weiss | Summit | C | 12 |
| Jaden McReynolds | Union Catholic | OF | 11 |
| Dylan Donohue | Union Catholic | P/1B | 12 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Nicholas McCaffery | Arthur L. Johnson | OF | 12 |
| Shane Mulroy | Arthur L. Johnson | P | 11 |
| Ryan Sherman | New Providence | P | 12 |
| Stanton Leuthner | New Providence | SS | 12 |
| Nate Scott | New Providence | IF/P | 11 |
| Thomas Friscia | New Providence | OF | 12 |
| Patrick Hartnett | Union Catholic | SS | 11 |
Valley Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Vincent Rappa | David Brearley | P/OF | 12 |
| Gustavo Carreto | David Brearley | CF | 10 |
| Ibn McLean | David Brearley | LF | 11 |
| Michael Cacioppo | Jonathan Dayton | SS | 11 |
| Vinny Pulice | Jonathan Dayton | P | 12 |
| Zach Celo | Jonathan Dayton | 1B | 11 |
| Austin Urban | Linden | P | 12 |
| Nicholas Johns | Linden | CF | 12 |
| Nick DeMarinis | Oratory Prep | 1B | 12 |
| Andrew Meisner | Oratory Prep | P | 12 |
| Jack Reilly | Oratory Prep | P | 12 |
| Jack Greco | Oratory Prep | 3B | 10 |
| Jayson Gonzalez | Rahway | SS | 11 |
| Nate Nunez | Roselle Park | OF | 11 |
| Josh De La Rosa | Roselle Park | OF | 12 |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Michael Graham | David Brearley | 1B | 10 |
| Quinn Lonergan | David Brearley | C | 9 |
| Jacob Pereira | Jonathan Dayton | 2B | 12 |
| Darren Teixeira | Jonathan Dayton | 2B | 11 |
| Jack Conway | Jonathan Dayton | RF | 12 |
| Aidan Elgrably | Jonathan Dayton | C | 12 |
| Christian Ortiz | Linden | 3B | 10 |
| Francisco Castillo | Linden | SS | 12 |
| Richard Zack | Linden | 1B/OF | 10 |
| Joe DelSol | Oratory Prep | 11 | |
| Will Demilt | Oratory Prep | 12 | |
| Ben Landis | Oratory Prep | 11 | |
| John Meehan | Oratory Prep | 12 | |
| Dave Shepherd | Rahway | 3B | 12 |
| Antonio Martins | Roselle Park | SS/P | 12 |
Sky Division
First Team
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Donovan Rentas | Abraham Clark | SS | 11 |
| Dave Lipscomb | Hillside | OF | 11 |
| Ronnie Wallraff | Hillside | P/SS | 12 |
| Lamar McLean | Hillside | C/P | 12 |
| Toran Smith | Plainfield | SS | 12 |
| Skyler Frye | Plainfield | C | 12 |
| Melfry Batista Pichardo | Plainfield | OF | 12 |
| Cameron Smith | Plainfield | P | 10 |
| Carlos Acosta | Plainfield | OF | 10 |
| Bryan Williams | Plainfield | P | 10 |
| Lucas Kidder | Plainfield | OF | 9 |
| Ryan Pernell | Plainfield | DH | 12 |
| James Howlett | Roselle Catholic | P | |
| Doug Shack | Roselle Catholic | OF | |
| Xavier Krok | Roselle Catholic | OF |
Honorable Mention
| Name | School | Position | Grade |
| Shemar Morrison | Abraham Clark | P | 12 |
| Angel Gonzalez | Abraham Clark | C | 10 |
| Chris Villainy | Abraham Clark | 3B | 10 |
| Justice Evans | Hillside | SS | 11 |
| Andy Cruz | Plainfield | OF | 12 |