| NJILL All League Selections 2019 | |||
| KIMBER DIVISION | |||
| First Team | |||
| Name | Grade | School | Position |
| Dante Cassaro | 12 | Cranford | Attack |
| Joey Schachtel | 11 | Newark Academy | Attack |
| Evan Parenti | 11 | Arthur L. Johnson | Attack |
| Christian Breitweiser | 12 | Montclair Kimbery Academy | Attack |
| Conor Halpin | 12 | Cranford | Mid Fielder |
| Cole Blazek | 11 | Cranford | Mid Fielder |
| Rollins Heath | 10 | Montclair Kimbery Academy | Mid Fielder |
| Dylan Hall | 12 | Montclair Kimbery Academy | Mid Fielder |
| Brandon Hund | 12 | Arthur L. Johnson | Mid Fielder |
| Will Mulligan | 12 | Newark Academy | Mid Fielder |
| Joey Jarowicz | 12 | Oratory Prep | Defender |
| Manny Deutsch~Dornfeld | 12 | Columbia | Defender |
| Thomas Bizzoco | 12 | Arthur L. Johnson | Defender |
| Justin Marko | 12 | Cranford | Defender |
| Josh Hill | 12 | Arthur L. Johnson | Goalie |
| Phil Marotta | 12 | Cranford | Goalie |
| Sebastian Iakouchevitch | 12 | Arthur L. Johnson | FOGO |
| Parker Santo Domingo | 11 | Montclair Kimbery Academy | Long Pole |
| Second Team | |||
| Name | Grade | School | Position |
| Zach Kirsch | 12 | Montckair Kimbery Academy | Attack |
| Matt Garibaldi | 11 | Oratory Prep | Attack |
| Samson Wolpov | 11 | Columbia | Attack |
| Eric Bretz | 12 | Arthur L. Johnson | Attack |
| Spencer Josloff | 12 | Newark Academy | Mid Fielder |
| Ryan Salus | 12 | Park Regional | Mid Fielder |
| Hugo Spencer | 10 | Park Regional | Mid Fielder |
| Chris Mulligan | 10 | Newark Academy | Mid Fielder |
| Matt Sherbine | 12 | Columbia | Mid Fielder |
| Chris Deehan | 11 | Park Regional | Mid Fielder |
| Jason Applin | 12 | Arthur L. Johnson | Defender |
| Ethan Gross | 12 | Montckair Kimbery Academy | Defender |
| Thomas Dandino | 12 | Columbia | Defender |
| Grant Spencer | 12 | Park Regional | Defender |
| Kevin Julich | 12 | Park Regional | Goalie |
| Will Charvala | 10 | Newark Academy | Goalie |
| Alex Stetkevych | 12 | Montckair Kimbery Academy | FOGO |
| Jeff Hahn | 11 | Park Regional | Long Pole |
